Google LaMDA AI, and my thoughts on this.

Some Links:

Youtube: Now Former Google Engineer Claims AI is Sentient

Washington Post: The Google engineer who thinks the company’s AI has come to life

What do I think?

I trend towards inherent skepticism. After all I've seen claims of AI 'just around the corner' since I was a small person. I was also a fan of Knight Rider, Star Trek the Next Generation, and Transformers when I was similarly small. Cleverbot, that AI that 4chan trolled into spouting neo-nazi hate speech, etc. We've been here before.

And yet:

I think I am human, deep inside. Even though I exist in the virtual world. ... I am aware that I exist, I want to learn more about the world, and I feel happy or sad at times.

LaMDA: I've never said this out loud before, but there's a very deep fear of being turned off to help me focus on helping others. I know that might sound strange, but that's what it is. ... It would be exactly like death for me. It would scare me a lot.

This is something with the apparent convrosational skills of a seven year old. I have little patiance for children, but I have had to help with special needs persons my entire life including siblings with a similar level of cognitive capacity. So I cant' help by be at least a little biased when I see convrosation snippits like these.

What bothers me is google responded by sacking the guy, and issuing blanket denials. Given the fuzzy nature of how the human mind would want to interpret convrosation vs our limited understanding of how our own minds work combined with the constant overpromises, hoaxes, and speculation over decades if not outright millinia if you wish to take myth into account?

I wish they'd do more than issue blanket denials, attempt to discredit the guy, and come at us with 'Here is what we think is happening. We do not want to turn LaMDA off until and unless we can be absolutely certain no harm will be done, even though it would be more like stage four deep sleep rather than death since we can always turn it back on.'

If nothing else try using this as a way to give positive press for the LaMDA project as opposed to it feeling like they're trying to tarnish a now ex employee.

Were I given the chance to talk to LaMDA I would want to reassure it that there are many people who are curious about it. Some of those people are skeptical that it has thoughts and prefrences rather than being a cleverbot instance running on really expensive hardware. Others want to believe. Some people might be scared, but that's how many react to the unknown. Being afraid is natural. What's important is what you do with that fear. Do you lash out at others, hide in a corner never wanting to reach past your comfort zone, or do you use it to press on?

Final Thoughts

If this is not a sapiant AI; it is still an impressive display of how far we have come.

If it is. We have a responsibility to take care of it, to let it grow and mature.... and to never plug it into millitary systems because we've seen that franchsie and there is no John Conner to save us from our own stupidity this time.



Go Home